Wanted: CFD Mesh and Solution Data For Analysis of Mesh Quality Effects on Solution Accuracy
This site is intended to serve as a repository for data that can be
used to study the interaction between mesh quality and solution
accuracy. I've set this site up both to collect data that will
be useful to me in my own research and to distribute that data to
other researchers with similar interests.
If you're here, you probably don't need to be convinced that this is a
problem, but in case you do, here's a thumbnail overview, including some thoughts
on how such data could be used.
Obviously, for this repository to work, we need data. Here are some
guidelines for those interested in contributing data:
- To keep the scope of analysis to a reasonable level, solution data
should be for steady state and based on either the Euler or
Navier-Stokes equations. Both laminar and turbulent viscous flow
solutions are welcome; thin-layer approximations are fine,
too.
- Solution data should be created by CFD solvers that are
well-verified and well-validated. If your code isn't producing
physically and numerically sensible solutions, you've got worse
problems than mesh quality.
- The data should not be proprietary, classified, or otherwise
restricted in how it can be distributed. By default, solution data
will be posted for outgoing FTP access, with one exception, listed
below.
- Bad solution data is likely to be at
least as useful as good solution data! So don't be shy about sending in solutions where you thought
everything should go right and it didn't. If the solution is bad
enough that you don't want it distributed with your name on it, let me
know. I can either distribute it without attribution or not
distribute it publicly at all.
This is a repository for sharing research data, not a consulting
service. While I'm happy to try to answer questions of the form, "Why
can't we get a good answer for this problem? My client / boss needs
to know immediately!" that's obviously a consulting question, not a
research question. So please contact me directly with questions like
this rather than just uploading your data; you're much more likely to
get a quick response that way.
How To Upload Data
Each submission should be a self-contained compressed archive (.tgz,
.tar.bz2, .zip, etc), including a copy of the appropriate data from,
solution data, mesh data, code fragments that will read the solution
and mesh data (unless the file format is one commonly read by
commercial post-processing software), and any other information about
the problem that the data form requests or that you think might be
useful.
In the very near future, we'll have a set of CGNS-based I/O routines
available for use, providing a common file format that won't require
anyone to write I/O code to read anyone else's data.
- Data for cases from the Fourth AIAA Drag Prediction Workshop
should use this data form and
be uploaded to ftp://mesh-quality.mech.ubc.ca/pub/incoming/DPW4.
- Data for other aerodynamics problems should use this data form and be uploaded
to ftp://mesh-quality.mech.ubc.ca/pub/incoming/aero.
- Data for other problems should use this data form and be uploaded to
ftp://mesh-quality.mech.ubc.ca/pub/incoming/other.
How To Download
All publicly available data is served from ftp://mesh-quality.mech.ubc.ca/pub/outgoing.
Questions / comments? Contact Carl Ollivier-Gooch (cfog@mech.ubc.ca).